Transition Voice

The magazine on peak oil and the Transition movement

  • Home
  • Books
  • Climate
  • Energy
  • Politics
  • Spirit
You are here: Home / Climate / The shock doctrine hits climate change

The shock doctrine hits climate change

By Erik Curren | April 4, 2011

threat level poster

What, me worry? Not about climate change. The real threat is to free-market capitalism, say big corporations. Photo: Derek Purdy via Flickr.

“Only a crisis produces real change. When that crisis occurs, the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around,” said free-market saint Milton Friedman.

Today, as the world reels from recession, unemployment and civil unrest all while facing an oil shock and worsening symptoms of climate change, Friedman’s disciples hope to capitalize on today’s crisis.

And what’s the idea they want to pick up? It’s simple, really: Ordinary people need to make sacrifices so that big corporations can thrive.

Corporate globalization is your daddy

After all, the argument goes, only big business can create jobs and keep us all out of bread lines. So if we want economic recovery, then we all need to tighten our belts, accept lower wages, give up unions and forget about do-gooder nanny-state luxuries like taking care of the environment.

Naomi Klein, author of The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism, gave this message to a packed hall in Totnes in England, where she had little praise for those who are supposed to be protecting us from dangerous anthropogenic propaganda about climate science.

The climate movement hasn’t just failed to make progress in the last few years. It’s actually going backwards politically, even as the science continues to get more certain and the situation on the ground gets more dire.

Last year’s failed cap-and-trade campaign blew any chance for serious climate action for years not only in Washington but worldwide.

And the movement hasn’t wised up much since, insisting on sticking to either one of two failed strategies:

  1. Keep your head down just talk about the science while pretending the ideological war between science and denial doesn’t exist, or
  2. Try to appeal to the mentality of the right (“hey you free-marketers, climate change can actually be good for capitalism by creating lucrative opportunities for entrepreneurs”).

Traitors to the free market

But despite Palin and misspelled Tea Party signs, the right isn’t stupid when it comes to what it would really mean to accept climate science.

If you admit that climate change is real, that it’s caused by industry and that it’s dangerous, then you must also agree to regulate globalized capitalism. So there goes the free market.

“The green tree has red roots,” as conservative columnist George Will wrote.

So it’s not about melting icecaps. It’s about socialism.

How can climate activists fight that? First, they need to listen better to the actual claims made on the right. Then, Klein says, activists need to hit those claims head on.

Watch video excerpts from Klein’s Talk sent out last week by Transition Network co-founder Rob Hopkins. Klein’s brilliant analysis is must-see TV.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • More
  • Print
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • WhatsApp

Filed Under: Climate Tagged With: climate skeptics, Great Recession, Naomi Klein, plutocracy, Totnes, unemployment

About Erik Curren

Erik Curren is the publisher of Transition Voice and the author of four books on Buddhism and solar power. His most recent title, Abolish Oil Now! Abolitionists Beat Slavery and Can Beat Climate Change, was published in October 2021.

Comments

  1. Shayne says

    April 4, 2011 at 6:10 pm

    Thank you for this Eric. Everyone in the green movement needs to hear these words.

    Log in to Reply
    • Erik Curren says

      April 4, 2011 at 8:06 pm

      Thanks Shayne, I appreciate your kind comment!

      Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Most Popular Stories

  • Five Bummer Problems that Make Societies Collapse
  • The daily grind, Amish style
  • Beyond capitalism with a human face: a radically simple way
  • Cut off from society, sports become junk
  • The Cotton Gin Paradox
  • New take on the cowboy tie is back
  • How to Talk to a Climate 'Skeptic'
  • Raising a garden bed: build or buy?
  • Seeing the choice: the New Existentialism (Part 2)
  • Inspiration for the burned-out localizer
  • Home
  • Books
  • Climate
  • Energy
  • Politics
  • Spirit
  • About us
  • Resources
  • Contact

© 2022 Transition Voice · Web design by Curren Media Group · Log in